愛污传媒

Skip to main content

Seoul rolls out new AI-based surveillance system to stop suicides; privacy experts divided

A night view of South Korea's capital Seoul with the Han River is seen in Seoul, South Korea, Friday, Aug. 7, 2020. (AP Photo/Lee Jin-man) A night view of South Korea's capital Seoul with the Han River is seen in Seoul, South Korea, Friday, Aug. 7, 2020. (AP Photo/Lee Jin-man)
Share
TORONTO -

The Seoul Metropolitan Government has announced a new pilot project to address suicides on bridges spanning the Han River, the main waterway bisecting the city, by rolling out  an AI-based surveillance system paired with a new CCTV camera control hub that uses deep learning to identify the 鈥減atterns鈥 of people in crisis.

Currently, Seoul has CCTV operators working on three rotating shifts that cover 24 hours a day, seven days a week, at four different control centres in the Yeouido, Banpo, Ttukseom and Gwangnaru neighbourhoods on the river.

In a statement emailed to CTVNews.ca, the Seoul Metropolitan Government said it has been operating a CCTV surveillance and response system since 2012 on the Mapo and Seogang Bridges spanning the Han River, as they have the highest number of suicide attempts, monitoring the bridges 24 hours a day and 鈥減roactively responding to suicide attempts.鈥

From 2015 to 2018, the Seoul Metropolitan Government invested approximately CAD$10.3 million to expand their system to eight more bridges, installing 20 CCTV systems comprising three types 鈥 fixed, rotating and thermographic cameras - on all 10 bridges.

The system allows rescuers to monitor the bridge through 572 CCTVs in real-time and arrive at the scene in four minutes, the statement said.

In a press release, the government explained that the new partnership between the Seoul Institute of Technology and the Seoul Fire&Disaster Headquarters (SFDH) is aimed at improving the current suicide detection system - and has been analyzing data from SFDH since April 2020.

The data includes dispatch reports, CCTV footage, data from bridge sensors, information from people who had previously attempted suicide, report history, phone calls and text messages.

The AI system would then send the CCTV footage that it flagged to a monitoring agent at the new integrated control centre to dispatch the relevant authorities.

鈥淭his system allows rapid responses to suicide attempts鈥攂oth before or after an incident鈥攁nd minimizes surveillance loopholes. Not only that, but it can also dramatically reduce warning errors thanks to AI鈥檚 ability to reflect environmental factors, including illumination levels and weather, as well as characteristics of Han River bridges such as wobbling caused by winds and traffic. As data accumulates, the accuracy of the system will increase further,鈥 the release states.

According to the Seoul Metropolitan Government, every year approximately 486 people attempt suicide on bridges spanning the Han River and authorities are able to save 96.63 per cent.

While many would laud the purpose of such a high-tech solution to a social issue that is rampant in South Korea 鈥 the country with the highest rate of suicides amongst OECD countries -- privacy experts remain divided on the merits of such a program and whether this would be approved for use in Canada.

SURVEILLANCE INFRASTRUCTURE

South Korea鈥檚 surveillance infrastructure is vast. In 2015, the estimated that the CCTV cameras across the country numbered in the millions - with more than 115,891 CCTV cameras newly installed by the government in public places in 2019, according to a estimate. And that number is expected to grow.

In its emailed statement, the Seoul Metropolitan Government said that as of December 2020, the city was managing 75,431 CCTVs 鈥渋nstalled for security, facility management and traffic safety.鈥

The country鈥檚 has strict compliance requirements for both the private and public sector when it comes to identifying information. However, government agencies that require personal data for public interest purposes can collect and use data without the need to obtain consent 鈥 for many Koreans, surveillance on such a scale is simply a part of daily life.

This played out in South Korea鈥檚 , where health authorities could zero-in on contact tracing with astonishing precision thanks to the .

Health authorities could conduct an investigation using CCTV, credit card transaction data and mobile phone tracking to warn close contacts of their exposure to someone with COVID-19, and to dispatch sterilization teams to disinfect areas the person had visited.

Emergency alert text messages were sent to all mobile phones through Korea鈥檚 cellular broadcasting service, which was also used by the government and health authorities to update citizens on new cases and issue warnings on COVID-19 hot spots.

That kind of surveillance and data gathering in other countries like Canada would be blocked by more stringent data protection and privacy laws.

And while an AI-based surveillance system may assist authorities to help someone in a crisis 鈥 privacy experts are divided on whether the end result justifies the means.

Former Ontario privacy commissioner Ann Cavoukian said that while its 鈥渁dmirable鈥 the Seoul Metropolitan Government is addressing concerns about suicide, using AI-enabled CCTV is an 鈥渆ncroachment on privacy.鈥

鈥淎t the very least, the government should be providing signage and give notice to the public walking on these bridges that these new measures are in effect,鈥 Cavoukian said in a telephone interview with CTVNews.ca. 鈥淭here will be no privacy, and people should be made fully aware that when they walk on that bridge, their identity is being captured, along with what they鈥檙e doing.鈥

Cavoukian said she doesn鈥檛 believe a program like Seoul鈥檚 would be authorized for use in Canada, as 鈥減eople don鈥檛 want to be tracked.鈥

鈥淭hat鈥檚 what this will enable you to do, whether you do it intentionally or not,鈥 she said. 鈥淥nce it starts, that鈥檚 what will happen, and then law enforcement will use it鈥n the last two years concern for privacy has been on an all time high, so I don鈥檛 think it would be popular here personally.鈥

David Fraser, a privacy lawyer with McInness Cooper in Halifax, N.S., disagrees 鈥 but says the program would have to be monitored closely.

鈥淯sing video surveillance technologies, particularly when coupled with something that resembles biometrics, more resembles artificial intelligence,鈥 Fraser said in a telephone interview. 鈥淭here's a real good reason to be nervous about that and to scrutinise it very closely.鈥

However, Fraser said that 鈥渁t the end of the day鈥 Seoul鈥檚 pilot project is a 鈥渧ery interesting鈥 application of AI technology that鈥檚 鈥渃learly intended to reduce the loss of life and actually proactively save people鈥檚 lives.鈥

鈥淩eally, what could be the negative impacts or implications for individuals other than perhaps you have a pedestrian crossing the bridge with no intention to harm themselves and having an intervention,鈥 Fraser said of the program. 鈥淚 think I would be supportive of the project as long as the kind of diligence has also gone into making sure that the images and videos they're collecting in order to feed their machine learning is appropriately protected, with appropriate controls.鈥

And while Canada does not have the same mass surveillance culture that South Korea has, Fraser pointed out that CCTV cameras in places like subway stations, train stations and bus stations could be eligible places for a program like Seoul鈥檚 should Canada want to implement it.

鈥淚 think you would probably find the nearest subway station in Canada is covered in every square inch with CCTV cameras,鈥 Fraser said. 鈥淚f such a programme were to be proposed in Canada, those transit authorities are all public sector, and all subject to privacy laws that regulate the collection use and disclosure of personal information, which for some information includes video images.鈥

Fraser said any such program proposed in Canada would have to go through a rigorous process known as a 鈥淧rivacy Impact Assessment,鈥 which weighs the ethical and logical scope of any policy that could impact Canadians鈥 privacy 鈥 including only collecting the information needed and to minimise the collection of any data that is not needed, and supervision of the analysis of said data.

'FUNCTION CREEP'

The Seoul Metropolitan Government denied in its statement that there were privacy concerns associated with the project, saying it had been 鈥減rovided with de-identified video data from the Seoul Fire & Disaster Headquarters for scientific research purposes only to extract 鈥榝eatures鈥 for deep learning." The statement reiterated "there is no possibility to raise concern [sic] because the video data is discarded after use according to security procedures on a monthly basis.鈥

Fraser likened Seoul鈥檚 pilot project to the phenomena of people giving up private medical information in order to raise awareness or to assist in research to prevent 鈥渨hat happened to them happening to others.鈥

However, Fraser did echo Cavoukian鈥檚 concerns about the potential for the erosion of privacy, saying he was cautious of 鈥渇unction creep.鈥

鈥淪o cameras were probably put there in the first place for a specific purpose鈥 including identifying people at risk of self-harm,鈥 Fraser said. 鈥淏ut putting in any new technology, that changes the game.鈥

Fraser said ethical complications can arise when seemingly innocent ideas on expanding the mandate of the original system are put forward.

鈥淲hat happens when somebody says, 鈥楬ey, we have a problem with pickpockets, so let's tweak the model so we can identify people who are pickpocketing?鈥欌 Fraser said. 鈥淭he tweaks seem incremental and before you know it, we have a surveillance system that's identifying people and leading to law enforcement interventions - you just have to look at wellness checks and police interventions to see how often those end in really bad outcomes.鈥

Fraser said any project like Seoul鈥檚 has to be preceded by 鈥渃arefully asking ourselves the appropriate questions.鈥

鈥淚 think we also need to always be doing a bit of a reality check when it comes to this -- societally, how are we with this?鈥

------

With files from Reuters

MENTAL HEALTH RESOURCES

If you are experiencing a mental health crisis and need to speak with someone, here are available resources:

Crisis Services Canada, enables callers anywhere in Canada to access crisis support by phone, in French or English: toll-free 1-833-456-4566 Available 24/7

Correction

This story has been updated with a more accurate count of the CCTV cameras in South Korea

CTVNews.ca Top Stories

It's a dream for many Canadians, trying to save up enough money for a down payment on their very first home. That was also the dream for the Esmeralda family, a family of five with two dogs who currently live in a Scarborough apartment building.

Donations are quickly pouring in for the family of a young woman who was found dead inside a Walmart in Halifax last weekend.

A haunted house in the Ontario Town of Innisfil is causing a real scare for some people a week before Halloween.

Four people are dead and another is in hospital following a fiery crash in downtown Toronto that happened overnight on Lake Shore Boulevard.

Local Spotlight

He is a familiar face to residents of a neighbourhood just west of Roncesvalles Avenue.

A meteor lit up our region's sky last night 鈥 with a large fireball shooting across the horizon over Lake Erie at around 7:00 p.m.

Residents of Ottawa's Rideauview neighbourhood say an aggressive wild turkey has become a problem.

A man who lost his life while trying to rescue people from floodwaters, and a 13-year-old boy who saved his family from a dog attack, are among the Nova Scotians who received a medal for bravery Tuesday.

A newly minted Winnipegger is hoping a world record attempt will help bring awareness for the need for more pump track facilities in the city.

A Springfield, Ont. man is being hailed a 'hero' after running into his burning home to save his two infant children.

Hortense Anglin was the oldest graduate to make her way across the platform at York University's Fall Convocation ceremony this week. At the age of 87, she graduated with an Honours degree in Religious Studies.

Looking for a scare with good intentions this Halloween season? The ghosts and ghouls of Eganville, Ont. invite families to tour the Haunted Walk at Lekbor Manor.

The image of a sleepy Saskatchewan small town with 'not a lot going on' is a well-known anecdote. However, one Saskatchewan company is hoping to change that 鈥 and allow communities both on and off the beaten path to share their stories and advertise what they have to offer.