愛污传媒

Health

    • Are we ready? Should we do this? The debate on expanding medical assistance in dying

    Federal Justice Minister Arif Virani takes part in an interview in Ottawa on Wednesday, Dec. 13, 2023. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick Federal Justice Minister Arif Virani takes part in an interview in Ottawa on Wednesday, Dec. 13, 2023. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick
    Share
    OTTAWA -

    The federal Liberals face a choice early in 2024.

    They can allow a sunset clause to take effect so that eligibility for medical assistance in dying expands to adults whose only reason for seeking it is a mental disorder.

    Or they can do what they did in 2023 and postpone it further, even indefinitely.

    Justice Minister Arif Virani says the government is weighing its options as the March deadline looms.

    The first step, he says, will be to see what members of Parliament and senators recommend after committee hearings that probed the issue this past fall.

    To find answers, The Canadian Press spoke with many of the medical and legal experts who participated in that process.

    Here are five questions that strike at the heart of the debate.

    IS CANADA READY?

    Assessors and providers of medical assistance in dying, as well as medical regulators, say they are ready for eligibility to be widened.

    鈥淥ur hope is that government will not be influenced by the concern that the regulators will not be ready,鈥 says Gus Grant, the CEO and registrar of Nova Scotia's College of Physicians and Surgeons.

    Since medical assistance in dying became legal in 2016, many voices have sounded the alarm about whether the medical profession was ready to handle changes.

    鈥淭hose voices proved to be wrong at each occasion,鈥 Grant, who is also a past president of the Federation of Medical Regulatory Authorities of Canada, said in an interview.

    鈥淭he medical regulators and the involved health-care professionals were ready.鈥

    The argument that the system can't handle change usually comes from those who would rather not see the program expand at all, Grant and others said. It also ignores the reality that some patients with mental illness can already access assisted dying if they have other medical conditions.

    鈥淚t's a bit like Lucy and Charlie Brown and the football, right?鈥 said Jocelyn Downie, a professor at Halifax's Dalhousie University

    鈥淵ou put the football down, 'OK, we're gonna get this ready, boom.' And then the next time, the football gets pulled out from under you.鈥

    Sonu Gaind, chief of the Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre's psychiatry department and a University of Toronto professor, is among those asking the government to pause its expansion plans and 鈥渞e-evaluate how we got here.鈥

    There are questions that are 鈥渘owhere鈥 close to being addressed, he said, such as how practitioners can assess factors such as poverty and whether someone suffering with a mental disorder can get better or not.

    鈥淒oes it mean if you've had decades of suffering from an illness, and you've tried things, and nothing has helped? Is that what it means?鈥 he said.

    鈥淥r does it mean that you're suffering now, and you live in a rural community, Indigenous population, and you can't get access to care, and society is not willing to provide you access to care?鈥

    DOES CONSENSUS MATTER?

    Conservative MP Ed Fast cited a lack of expert consensus on whether the expansion should go ahead when he asked the House of Commons to change the Criminal Code to say a mental disorder is not listed as a 鈥済rievous and irremediable medical condition鈥 under the assisted dying regime.

    Fast's private member's bill ultimately failed, but MPs and senators who sat on the special joint committee saw the divide for themselves.

    鈥淭here's too much controversy,鈥 said Jitender Sareen, a physician at the University of Manitoba's psychiatry department.

    Many psychiatrists are opposed to assisted dying for people who only have a mental illness, he said, and organizations such as the Canadian Mental Health Association and the Canadian Association of Suicide Prevention have raised concerns about it.

    The hearings revealed the 鈥渟ignificant amount of concern among psychiatrists,鈥 said Sareen, who suggested the government should instead focus on better access to mental health care.

    Stefanie Green, one of the first doctors to provide medical assistance in dying after it was legalized, said in an email that the public, clinicians and academics have a right to disagree with the expansion, but that does not mean Canada shouldn't go ahead.

    She told the committee that other medical practices are available despite a lack of consensus, such hormone replacement therapy for women experiencing menopause and supervised injection sites for drug users.

    Provinces are also split.

    While New Brunswick says it's working to ensure it is ready and a spokesperson for Ontario's Health Ministry cited no concerns, Quebec passed a law in June excluding adults from accessing a medically assisted death solely for a mental disorder.

    A Saskatchewan government spokesman said it, too, is concerned with the planned expansion and 鈥渃annot commit鈥 to implementing it 鈥渨ithout carefully considering the risk that this may pose to people suffering from mental illness.鈥

    HAS THE ISSUE BEEN STUDIED ENOUGH?

    In 2021, Parliament passed an updated version of its medical assistance in dying law that expanded eligibility to people who only have a mental illness, and included a two-year sunset clause before it would take effect.

    The government struck an expert panel to probe whether more safeguards were needed and to make recommendations around assessments.

    The panel's final report in May 2022 recommended the government develop practice standards but suggested no more legislative changes. The report didn't wade into the question of whether or not the expansion should happen at all, and its seven-month time frame inhibited wide consultation.

    Gaind and others warn that the scope was too narrow, and there has been too little scrutiny on how this part of the law came to be.

    The 2021 bill was prompted by a 2019 Quebec Superior Court decision that found it was unconstitutional to require that an individual's death needed to be reasonably foreseeable to be eligible for assisted dying.

    The bill didn't initially expand eligibility to those who only have a mental disorder. The Senate added that provision in an amendment that the government decided to approve.

    Early this year, Parliament passed legislation to add just one more year to the sunset clause, so that the provision would take effect in March 2024, with Liberals saying more time was needed to get the system ready.

    Trudo Lemmens, a University of Toronto professor in health policy and law, said he believes the government is moving too rapidly and ought to undertake a more careful study. He added the recent committee hearings were too short and at times overly combative.

    鈥淚 understand that they felt obliged to be to be fast because the (March) date is coming up so quickly.鈥

    WHAT HAPPENS IF THERE IS ANOTHER DELAY?

    In a recent interview with The Canadian Press, Virani expressed openness to adding more time to the sunset clause delaying the expansion in eligibility.

    But in the meantime, those who say it is time to proceed say people are in severe pain as they wait to see what happens.

    Mona Gupta, a psychiatrist at the Universite de Montreal who chaired the government's expert panel, said she is concerned about the message the conversation has sent to people with mental disorders, their families and all of society 鈥渁bout the status of people with mental disorders, about the way in which their rights can be considered to be optional.鈥

    Downie made the point that another pause could mean that the expansion never happens. Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre has vowed to scrap it if he forms the next government, and a federal election must take place no later than fall 2025.

    If eligibility is further delayed or banned outright, she said the government would likely be taken to court.

    鈥淭he very individuals who are ... enduring an intolerable suffering, they have to go to court and force the government to do what the (Charter of Rights and Freedoms) demands of it,鈥 Downie said.

    COULD A BAN BE CHALLENGED?

    When they amended the updated assisted dying legislation, senators said they believed excluding people with mental disorders from eligibility amounted to discrimination under the Charter.

    Critics say no court or law is currently forcing the government's hand on this issue.

    Lemmens, along with a host of other law professors across the country, issued an open letter early this year saying it is 鈥渞eckless鈥 to suggest that a constitutional right to assisted dying for such patients would be recognized by the courts.

    鈥淚n fact, there is for that reason on the contrary a strong argument to be made that the Charter requires adequate and equal protection against premature death of all persons with disabilities,鈥 the letter read.

    Lemmens said he hopes the committee acknowledges in its report, which the Liberals say will inform their next steps, that there are constitutional law experts who assert 鈥渢here is no clear constitutional obligation鈥 for a further expansion into mental illness.

    Still, others warn that future court challenges are inevitable.

    Shelley Birenbaum of the Canadian Bar Association said people with mental illnesses are entitled to the same 鈥渁utonomy and self-determination鈥 when it comes to their health as those suffering from a physical illness.

    鈥淎 total exclusion for all persons suffering from mental illness as a sole underlying condition is likely to be constitutionally challenged as violating the equality, security and liberty guarantees in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms,鈥 said the Toronto lawyer, who chaired the association's end-of-life working group.

    This report by The Canadian Press was first published Dec. 27, 2023.

    CTVNews.ca Top Stories

    BREAKING

    BREAKING

    The ongoing count of absentee ballots in B.C.鈥檚 nail-biting 2024 provincial election has put the NDP ahead of the Conservatives in the Surrey-Guildford riding.

    A group of Cape Breton firefighters are apologizing after four people showed up at a Halloween dance dressed in what appeared to be Ku Klux Klan costumes.

    Marred by several delays, the trial of alleged human traffickers Lauriston and Amber Maloney finally got underway on Monday in a Bradford courtroom, with a woman who worked and lived with the couple testifying.

    Canada

    • A group of Cape Breton firefighters are apologizing after four people showed up at a Halloween dance dressed in what appeared to be Ku Klux Klan costumes.

    • Marred by several delays, the trial of alleged human traffickers Lauriston and Amber Maloney finally got underway on Monday in a Bradford courtroom, with a woman who worked and lived with the couple testifying.

    • A B.C. man who went missing nearly 15 years ago, while facing multiple sexual abuse allegations, has been declared dead by the court 鈥 which found he likely died when a fire engulfed the airplane hangar where he was last seen.

    • Montreal's mayor says a welcome sign depicting a woman wearing a veil that adorns a lobby at city hall will be taken down in the name of secularism.

    World

    Politics

    Health

    Sci-Tech

    Entertainment

    Business

    Lifestyle

    Sports

    Autos

    Local Spotlight

    Epcor says it has removed more than 20,000 goldfish from an Edmonton stormwater pond.

    Witches and warlocks have been flocking to New Brunswick waterways this month, as a new Halloween tradition ripples across the province.

    New Brunswicker Jillea Godin鈥檚 elaborate cosplay pieces attract thousands to her online accounts, as well as requests from celebrities for their own pieces.

    A new resident at a Manitoba animal rescue has waddled her way into people's hearts.

    Hundreds of people ran to the music of German composer and pianist Beethoven Wednesday night in a unique race in Halifax.

    He is a familiar face to residents of a neighbourhood just west of Roncesvalles Avenue.

    A meteor lit up our region's sky last night 鈥 with a large fireball shooting across the horizon over Lake Erie at around 7:00 p.m.

    Residents of Ottawa's Rideauview neighbourhood say an aggressive wild turkey has become a problem.

    A man who lost his life while trying to rescue people from floodwaters, and a 13-year-old boy who saved his family from a dog attack, are among the Nova Scotians who received a medal for bravery Tuesday.

    • BREAKING

      BREAKING

      The ongoing count of absentee ballots in B.C.鈥檚 nail-biting 2024 provincial election has put the NDP ahead of the Conservatives in the Surrey-Guildford riding.

    • The last of three recounts in British Columbia's closely contested provincial election has concluded with B.C. NDP candidate Dana Lajeunesse still leading in the Juan de Fuca-Malahat riding.

    • A British Columbia political scientist says social media questioning of the provincial election's integrity is an "inevitable" result of political "toxicity" and a tight race.

    • The TTC is sharing details about how it plans to cope with the massive influx of Taylor Swift fans into Toronto鈥檚 core during the superstar鈥檚 six-show stay in the city.

    • An 'iconic' gorilla that has lived at the Toronto Zoo since it first opened in 1974 is experiencing health issues and will be kept from the public as he receives treatment.

    • New home sales in the Greater Toronto Area remained sluggish last month, but a new report suggests that the market is now primed for buyers following four consecutive interest rate cuts.

    • A Liberal member of Parliament says he's baffled by the Alberta United Conservative government's response to his private member's bill about pandemic preparedness.

    • Calgary鈥檚 Mission Bridge will be closed to motorists for several months as city crews complete rehabilitation work.

    • Another newly renovated hotel has opened its doors in Revelstoke, B.C.

    • Some of the people who knew Brkti Berhe, the woman killed in an Ottawa park in what police have said was femicide, are remembering her as a devoted wife, loving mother, and pillar of the community.

    • Grief counsellors are at Perth and District Collegiate Institute in Perth, Ont. today, as family, friends and the community mourn the death of 15-year-old Reese Stanzel.

    • Suspended Ottawa lawyer James Bowie has been ordered to pay $235,000 in damages to a former client after he repeatedly suggested she pay for his legal services with oral sex and released personal details about her online after the allegations were reported by 愛污传媒 Ottawa.

    • Advocates for the homeless say moving all centres 250 metres from daycares or schools would mean virtually no centres in Quebec would be able to operate.

    • A new study suggests Montrealers are going downtown less often with four in 10 saying they go less often than before the pandemic.

    • Ottawa said it will not challenge a Quebec law that allows people to request medical assistance in dying (MAID) in advance.

    • The Alberta Gaming, Liquor and Cannabis Commission says it is evaluating the relocation of the Camrose Casino after the company that owns it was forced into receivership.

    • Visitors at the West Edmonton Mall will see one less clapping critter at Sea Lions鈥 Rock.

    • A Bonnyville teacher has been accused of trying to lure a boy and his friends to her hotel room.

    • A group of Cape Breton firefighters are apologizing after four people showed up at a Halloween dance dressed in what appeared to be Ku Klux Klan costumes.

    • The Saint John Police Force is asking for the public鈥檚 help in locating a man wanted on a Canada-wide warrant in connection with a shooting incident in the city over the weekend.

    • Halifax Regional Police is investigating two break-and-enters in parking garages early Sunday morning.

    • Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew has honoured first responders for their actions following a fiery bus crash on the Trans-Canada Highway last year that killed 17 people.

    • Three youths were arrested after a senior was shot in the head with a BB gun early Monday morning.

    • Advocates say new data showing record food bank usage across Canada marks a somber milestone, while the Manitoba organization helping to feed those in need said they are being pushed to the brink by the unprecedented demand.

    • Candidates across Saskatchewan have made their final pitches to potential voters as the 2024 campaign comes to a close and election day arrives.

    • With multiple polls suggesting a tight race to the finish for Saskatchewan's major political parties 鈥 here are the ridings where some extra attention may be required.

    • Election day has arrived in Saskatchewan. With it, the last wave of voters prepare to cast their ballots and decide who will form government in the province.

    • What role does ideology play in the sentencing of the man who pleaded guilty to four charges in an attack at the University of Waterloo?

    • The Guelph Police Service is planning to dedicate more resources to ensuring public safety in the city鈥檚 downtown area as part of an ongoing initiative.

    • Police say just before 5 p.m. Friday, the suspects went to an address near Dawson Road and Shelldale Crescent and banged on the door.

    • Candidates across Saskatchewan have made their final pitches to potential voters as the 2024 campaign comes to a close and election day arrives.

    • With multiple polls suggesting a tight race to the finish for Saskatchewan's major political parties 鈥 here are the ridings where some extra attention may be required.

    • A construction worker who was robbed, shot and left for dead last week remains in a Saskatoon hospital awaiting more surgeries.

    • Ontario Premier Doug Ford in Sudbury on Monday afternoon to make an infrastructure funding announcement at a wastewater facility.

    • Two people were busted in Nipissing First Nation trying to use fake money to buy machinery, Anishinabek Police Service says.

    • A landlord in Sault Ste. Marie discriminated against a man who is deaf and has limited sight, the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal has ruled.

    • The first fully furnished tiny home in St. Thomas, Ont. has been unveiled as part of Project Tiny Hope.

    • London Food Bank鈥檚 co-executive director Jane Roy sees things like inflation, the rising cost of housing and insufficient social supports increasing the need for food banks.

    • A pickup truck and car collided in the Huron County village of Nile this afternoon, sending as many as five people to hospital.

    • Marred by several delays, the trial of alleged human traffickers Lauriston and Amber Maloney finally got underway on Monday in a Bradford courtroom, with a woman who worked and lived with the couple testifying.

    • On Monday, the Ontario government revealed it had awarded a major contract to Miller/Brennan to manage construction of the western section of the Bradford Bypass in Simcoe County.

    • The City of Barrie released data revealing its two automated speed enforcement cameras have helped to significantly curb speeding in community safety zones, with more than 18,000 tickets issued in five months.

    • Windsor police officers are asking for the public鈥檚 help to identify two suspects related to the death of a 69-year-old man in south-central Windsor.

    • Expect lane restrictions on your morning commute on Tuesday and Wednesday.

    • With more and more people turning to food banks for help, operators in Windsor-Essex are looking for a government intervention.

    • BREAKING

      BREAKING

      The ongoing count of absentee ballots in B.C.鈥檚 nail-biting 2024 provincial election has put the NDP ahead of the Conservatives in the Surrey-Guildford riding.

    • The last of three recounts in British Columbia's closely contested provincial election has concluded with B.C. NDP candidate Dana Lajeunesse still leading in the Juan de Fuca-Malahat riding.

    • A British Columbia political scientist says social media questioning of the provincial election's integrity is an "inevitable" result of political "toxicity" and a tight race.

    • More than two years after Alannah Brown and Douglas Barker were found dead north of Penticton, police are asking for help identifying a vehicle they believe was associated with the crime.

    • Dave Lindsey began growing giant pumpkins to bring a bit of magic to his grandkids' Halloween.

    • A U.S. District Court judge in Montana has sentenced a 27-year-old man from Kelowna, B.C., to 18 months in prison for using fake names to buy guns with the aim of selling them in Canada.

    • RCMP say a Medicine Hat man was killed in a collision between an SUV and a motorcycle in southeast Alberta on Sunday evening.

    • A tentative agreement has been reached between the City of Lethbridge and more than 900 employees belonging to CUPE Local 70.

    • The Hurricanes will be happy to be back home in Lethbridge Saturday night after losing their third in a row on the road Friday night, a 4-1 decision to the Broncos in Swift Current.

    • A landlord in Sault Ste. Marie discriminated against a man who is deaf and has limited sight, the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal has ruled.

    • One person has been charged after police in the Sault received a report of someone asleep at the wheel last weekend in a parking lot on Bay Street.

    • Ontario Provincial Police say three people have been charged with arson following a fire at a Sioux Lookout apartment building Friday night.

    N.L.

    Shopping Trends

    The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at 愛污传媒. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop.聽Read about us.

    Stay Connected
    Follow 愛污传媒